Privacy and sovereignty

Your data, under European law.

Where your data is stored is only half the story. What matters is who decides over it. Here we explain why that counts, which laws apply, and what Slate does differently.

The CLOUD Act

An American law that reaches into Europe.

The CLOUD Act (Clarifying Lawful Overseas Use of Data Act) is a United States federal law from March 2018.

It requires providers of communication and cloud services under US jurisdiction to disclose data in their "possession, custody, or control" when a US authority demands it with a warrant or order. Whether that data is stored inside the United States or outside it makes no difference.

So a data centre in Frankfurt or Amsterdam changes nothing, as long as the company that runs it is under US jurisdiction. A provider can object in limited cases, but a US court decides.

The GDPR

Europe says: not just like that.

The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR, in Dutch the AVG) has applied across the European Union since 25 May 2018.

Article 48 of the GDPR says that a judgment or decision of a court or authority outside the EU that requires personal data to be transferred is only recognised if it is based on an international agreement, such as a mutual legal assistance treaty.

An American company with European customers can be caught between two laws that contradict each other. Whoever keeps their data there is caught with it.

GDPR, Article 48

"Any judgment of a court or tribunal and any decision of an administrative authority of a third country requiring a controller or processor to transfer or disclose personal data may only be recognised or enforceable in any manner if based on an international agreement [...]"

Schrems II

Struck down twice.

In Schrems II (C-311/18, 16 July 2020) the Court of Justice of the EU declared the Privacy Shield invalid, because US surveillance laws do not give Europeans protection essentially equivalent to that in the EU.

It was the second time: in 2015 its predecessor, Safe Harbour, had already been declared invalid. Since 2023 the EU-US Data Privacy Framework applies. It rests on a presidential order (Executive Order 14086), which a future US president can change.

For an organisation that means: an arrangement that holds today may be gone tomorrow. Data that never leaves Europe and European law does not have that problem.

A clean slate

What Slate does instead.

Slate starts with a clean slate: a computer that collects nothing about you and demands nothing of you. Each point below is a requirement on the product, not a slogan.

No telemetry

Slate sends nothing about your use home. Crash reports are sent only if you turn them on yourself.

No account needed

Slate works fully without an account. Signing in to binadit Workspace or another service is possible, never required.

AI on your own computer

Slate AI runs locally: speech, understanding and answers. The EU cloud model is optional, off by default and keeps nothing.

Services in the Netherlands

Updates, Store, AI models, crash reports and this website run on Binadit's own servers in Dutch data centres, under European law. No American cloud.

Open standards

IMAP and SMTP, CalDAV, CardDAV, WebDAV and OpenID Connect. So you are never locked in, not even with us.

Inspectable

Built on open-source software, with reproducible and signed builds. Organisations can mirror updates and apps on their own servers.

What Slate connects to.

With its default settings, Slate talks only to servers that Binadit runs itself.

ServiceWhereDefault
System updatesBinadit, the NetherlandsOn, signed and checked
Store and app updatesBinadit, the NetherlandsOn
AI model downloadsBinadit, the NetherlandsOnly when you turn on Slate AI
EU cloud modelBinadit, the NetherlandsOff
Crash reportsBinadit, the NetherlandsOff
TelemetryNowhereDoes not exist

Apps and sources you choose yourself, such as your browser or an app from another maker, follow their own rules. Slate always shows what access an app asks for.

Sources

  • Regulation (EU) 2016/679, the General Data Protection Regulation, Articles 44 to 49: EUR-Lex
  • CLOUD Act, Consolidated Appropriations Act 2018, Division V, and 18 U.S.C. § 2713: text of § 2713, US Department of Justice
  • Court of Justice of the EU, case C-311/18, Data Protection Commissioner v Facebook Ireland and Schrems, 16 July 2020: Curia
  • Executive Order 14086 and the EU-US Data Privacy Framework (adequacy decision of 10 July 2023): European Commission

This page explains, it is not legal advice.

Start with a clean slate.

For yourself or for your whole organisation.